Skip to content
Join our Newsletter

Bay Ridge Fights to Preserve Its Historic Monastery

More than 500 residents rally as development pressures reshape the neighborhood.

More than 500 Bay Ridge residents gathered Saturday outside Visitation Monastery Academy at 8902 Ridge Blvd. to urge the city’s Landmarks Preservation Commission to designate the historic property a landmark.

The site closed in June 2024 after serving the community for 175 years. A sale to private equity firm Integritas Capital is pending, sparking widespread concern since news of the proposed deal surfaced in August.

Residents fear the 7.5-acre property, which features Renaissance Revival architecture, a pond and habitat for federally protected hawks, could be demolished and replaced with apartment buildings.

“We gather here today to demand that the mayor of New York City and the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission protect all the grounds of Monastery Square,” said Caroline Cardillo, an alumna and chair of the Visitation Academy & Monastery Landmark Initiative.

City Councilmember Kayla Santosuosso, who previously said she was “completely left out” of the sale negotiations, also addressed the crowd.

“Greed should not win over a community’s value,” Santosuosso said. “Greed should not dictate what happens to this institution and this property. We should dictate what happens to this community and this property.”

The firm declined to comment, saying the sale had not been finalized.

The rally reflected growing tensions over development and the future of Bay Ridge’s residential character.

“It’s very unfortunate,” said Josephine Beckmann, district manager of Community Board 10. “The community should have a voice in the planning and not have developers come in and do what they want.”

Real estate attorney Paul Proulx offered a different perspective. He represented BWH Group, which proposed Fort Hamilton Mews, an 11-story apartment building planned for the site of a Staples store slated for demolition. At an April Community Board 10 meeting, residents questioned the project's impact on neighborhood character.

“There were big changes when the big-box stores came,” Proulx said. “This is providing homes for Bay Ridge. That’s the way cities grow. There has not been a lot of change over several decades. They need to get used to that and get used to disappointment.”

Fort Hamilton Mews received approval from the City Council and the New York City Department of City Planning in October. The site’s zoning was changed to allow an 11-story building, up from the previous four-story limit.

Santosuosso negotiated concessions with BWH Group, including a six-story setback and family-sized apartments, in an effort to address neighborhood concerns.

But beginning Jan. 1, City Council members will lose their final vote on certain land-use applications under a 2025 ballot proposal approved by voters. The change shifts that authority to the Department of City Planning.

“There won’t be the ability to vote,” Santosuosso said. “With developments, we won’t have a say, but just advise. They can take our vote, but not our voice.”

She said she will continue advocating to city agencies and developers to ensure neighborhood concerns are heard.

Bay Ridge could see more development under the city’s Affordable Housing Fast Track, which targets community districts with the lowest levels of affordable housing construction over the past five years. Brooklyn Community District 10 added just three affordable homes during that period, according to the Department of City Planning.

“Every neighborhood in every borough has a role to play in addressing our city's housing crisis,” said Sahiba Kaur, the department’s press secretary. She said the initiative preserves opportunities for public input and leaves Community Boards’ role unchanged.

Meanwhile, Santosuosso has begun organizing residents around the future of the Bay Ridge Triangle, an area between Fourth and Fifth avenues and 86th and 95th streets. Known for its gas stations, car dealerships, medical offices and small businesses, the area could face future development pressures.

The councilmember has been leading walking tours and plans more community engagement in the new year to give residents a voice before developers advance new proposals.

“It’s so special to see love many have for our neighborhood,” Santosuosso said. “We’re going to see some changes in the next decade. So, we’re going to band together.”



Megan McGibney

About the Author: Megan McGibney

Megan McGibney is a multi-generational New Yorker who is originally from Staten Island.
Read more


Comments