Think you know Brooklyn pizza? Sure, you’ve heard and tried the legends (Totonno's, Di Fara and L&B Spumoni Gardens). But there are a lot of choices in this borough, where you only have to walk just a few blocks for an excellent slice.
Here's where some devotees go when they want pizza perfection without the wait or hype photos.
Neapolitan flair meets NYC attitude. Famed for the burrata slice and their super thin, crispy crust.
📍 254 S. 2nd St., Williamsburg
Inventive pies, a hidden-ish address feel, plus an impressive whiskey selection.
📍 905 Church Ave., Kensington/Prospect Park South
Old-school, no-BS perfection. The classic slice that keeps it real. A true neighborhood standby.
📍 686 5th Ave., South Slope
Sheepshead Bay’s best-kept secret. The slices are gooey, crisp and criminally underrated.
📍 2201 Avenue X, Sheepshead Bay
A south Brooklyn classic with 60s charm. The grandma slice is a local legend, and the vintage atmosphere is simply the best.
📍 8610 5th Ave., Bay Ridge
Order a whole pie for the full effect and bring cash just in case (some old-school spots demand it). Brooklyn has more pizza than you have weekends, so skip the usual suspects and eat like a local.
