BK Reader
  • Neighborhoods
    • Bedford Stuyvesant
    • Brownsville
    • Bushwick
    • Crown Heights
    • East New York
    • Flatbush
    • Fort Greene / Clinton Hill
    • Prospect Heights
  • News
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Business & Innovation
    • Health & Wellness
    • Lifestyle & Culture
    • Non-Profit & Community
    • Policy & Government
  • Features
    • Black History Month
    • Community Health
    • Gentrification in Brooklyn
    • Local Voices
  • About
    • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Advertise with Us
    • Write For Us
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Sign up for our daily newsletter!

BK Reader
  • Neighborhoods
    • Bedford Stuyvesant
    • Brownsville
    • Bushwick
    • Crown Heights
    • East New York
    • Flatbush
    • Fort Greene / Clinton Hill
    • Prospect Heights
  • News
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Business & Innovation
    • Health & Wellness
    • Lifestyle & Culture
    • Non-Profit & Community
    • Policy & Government
  • Features
    • Black History Month
    • Community Health
    • Gentrification in Brooklyn
    • Local Voices
  • About
    • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Advertise with Us
    • Write For Us
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
BK Reader
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Sign up for our daily newsletter!

ADHD: A Fictitious Disease?

Nzinga Harrison, M.D. by Nzinga Harrison, M.D.
April 12, 2015
in Featured News, Healthy Start
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Ritalin_Methylphenidat

An article is making its way around Facebook news feeds that reports Leon Eisenberg, “the scientific father of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)” made the startling deathbed confession that ““ADHD is a prime example of a fictitious disease.”  It goes on to reinforce the idea that ADHD is a disease made up and propagated by pharmaceutical companies and physicians in the pockets of pharmaceutical companies, all with the end goal of making lots of money.  Of course when I read this article, I knew I would be writing a blog about it.

I get to talk about this issue from both personal and professional perspectives. Let’s tackle professional first: I’m a physician.  My specialties are psychiatry and addiction medicine.  My position on all illnesses/diseases/disorders is that ideal management is psychological and social, with the risk of medication taken only when the benefits of that medication supersede the risk.  I should clarify that by all illnesses, I mean mental and physical.  If your high blood pressure can be managed with diet, exercise and stress reduction, I would recommend trying that first, before reaching for a pill.

Likewise, if your depression can be managed with therapy, healthy nutrition, exercise and stress reduction, let’s try that before prescribing an antidepressant.  The bar for starting medications is in a different place depending on the severity of symptoms and the impact on functioning.  Even if you’ve never tried diet and exercise, if you come in with a blood pressure that is sky high and complaint of chest pain, I’m reaching for medication immediately.

The same is true for depression.  If you have suicidal ideations and a feeling that you are close to making an attempt — of course, we need to look at psychosocial factors, but medication is going to be at the top of my list of interventions as well.

Because child and adolescent brains are still in critical developmental periods, my professional stance is that the bar for starting medications is higher. Yes, this flies in the face of research that recommends stimulant medications as a first line treatment, but my stance is that ideally, for a child with ADHD or any other illness physical or mental, you try environmental interventions first — calm and structure the environment at home, behavioral therapy, family therapy, biofeedback, join forces with the teachers at school, make the school environment more accommodating, change the diet, increase physical activity, introduce mindfulness, evaluate and manage other emotional reactivity etc. etc. etc. (and even more etc).

However, the fact is that many families don’t have the resources to make those changes.  They don’t have the resources of time, money and access.  Taking it a step further, many don’t have the cognitive or emotional resources necessary to make the types of changes that would be effective.  And so, do we leave them with nothing?  Or in the absence of the ability to control symptoms with psychosocial interventions, do we offer a medication?  I think you know what my answer is.

Yes, ADHD is over diagnosed.  But that does not change the fact that undiagnosed ADHD is associated with increased physical injuries, drug addiction, early and lingering involvement with the legal system, early drop out from the educational system and possibly even an increased risk for premature death.  It boils my blood when I see inflammatory articles like this one.  Without question, the chaotic, poorly nutritional, crowded school environment that many of our children living in poorer communities experience is inflating the frequency of behavioral symptoms and causally — the diagnosis of ADHD.

Without question, our inability to tolerate boisterous children inflates it as well.  Without question, pharmaceutical companies have made LOTS of money.  And without question, there are physicians in the pockets of pharmaceutical companies — acting more in the role of marketing consultants than stewards of good health. But to say ADHD doesn’t exist, and to make medication the villain is a blatant refusal to look at the entire system.

I get to speak from two angles, and the second is that I’m a mother. My oldest son irrefutably has ADHD.  Luckily, I was a psychiatrist and noticed that his behavior was not because he was a bad kid, but that there was likely something going on at the brain level.

Luckily, we had the resources to pull him out of traditional school, put him in Montessori school and get a full psychological evaluation. Luckily, my husband and I had the cognitive and emotional resources to make the changes in our home environment that the psychologist recommended.  Luckily, my son had teachers who are fully on board and understand his behavior rather than blame him.  Luckily, he goes to a school that offers yoga and meditation.  Luckily, our income allows us to afford soccer, track, swimming, drums, in-home internet for access to yoga videos and a treadmill in the house for those times when he urgently needs to burn off some energy.

Luckily, we had the time, money, access, time, money, access, time, money, access and more time, money, and access.  I believe directly as a result of that time, money and access, we are not on medications.  But trust me, we are lucky that we can mitigate the risk of ADHD with all the other resources we have.  If we didn’t have those resources, the risk of his ADHD being untreated would far outweigh the risk of a medication and we would be taking a pill every day.  In fact, he is 9 now, and we are not yet out of the woods.  If at any point we are unable to continue to manage his ADHD and it begins interfering with his functioning, trust me, we will be getting a prescription — STAT.

So yes, over diagnosis of ADHD is a problem.  It’s dangerous and it disproportionately affects children who live in poorer communities. And yes, there is definitely a system that is profiting off this diagnosis.  However, to say that ADHD is a fictional diagnosis is just as, if not more dangerous than, over-diagnosing it.

By creating this stigma, it removes responsibility to fix the system (disproportionate access to time, money and resources) and pushes more young people and families into a sinkhole where the help they need is inaccessible.

This post can be found in its entirety at my website: www.nzingaharrisonmd.com

ShareTweetSend

Did you enjoy this story? Please help us continue to bring you Brooklyn's latest local news for free by donating $1 here!

Related Posts

Gabourey Sidibe broke barriers, defied stereotypes and is defining her own success

Feb 18: Black History Maker, Gabourey Sidibe

February 18, 2019
3-alarm fire burns through Fort Greene building containing apartments, businesses

3-Alarm Fire Burns Through Fort Greene Building Containing Apartments, Businesses

February 18, 2019
Talib Kweli Kicked Off Valentine’s Weekend With A Love Note To Brooklyn

Talib Kweli Kicked off Valentine’s Weekend with a Love Note to Brooklyn

February 17, 2019
Permits Filed for 1694 St. Marks Avenue in Crown Heights, Brooklyn

Permits Filed for 1694 St. Marks Avenue in Crown Heights

February 17, 2019
Load More
Next Post

Henri Federic Amiel and Gardens

Comments 2

  1. Penny Williams says:
    4 years ago

    Thank you so much for disputing that ridiculous article so eloquently. It is very much about time, money, and access. I agree that every family should try non-pharmaceutical interventions first, but I also know (first-hand) that sometimes ADHD medication is the only way a child (or adult) has the opportunity to achieve success and happiness.

    Your son (and your family) is very fortunate to have all the time, money and access to help him achieve without medication. We don’t have money nor access for a specialty school, nor many treatments we’d like to try (like neurofeedback), but my son’s ADHD is so severe that he would need at least a little medication regardless. For him, the benefit greatly outweighs the risk.

    Penny Williams
    Author of “What to Expect When You’re Not Expecting ADHD” and “Boy Without Instructions: Surviving the Learning Curve of Parenting a Child with ADHD”
    ParentingADHDChildren.com

    Reply
    • Nzinga Harrison, M.D. says:
      4 years ago

      Penny,
      Thank you for your comment. I’ve re-read this blog so many times since I wrote it and have so many more things to say! You make one of the most important points that needs to be emphasized. Like every disorder, there is a spectrum of severity. Just because my son’s symptoms have been able to be managed with non-medication interventions, does not mean this will be everyone’s experience — regardless of time, money and access. There is an entire spectrum of ADHD severity from mild to severe (like all medical disorders: high blood pressure, anxiety, diabetes, obesity, depression etc) — and coupled with access, severity of symptoms will absolutely determine when and how early in the process medications need to be used. In my opinion, it is all about doing WHATEVER it takes and WHATEVER is available to give kids the best shot at being successful in life.

      And…your website is awesome 😉
      -Nzinga (AKA the Brainiac M.D.)

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

No Result
View All Result
Noel Pointer Auditions
ADVERTISEMENT
BHM Healthfirst 02 - Article
ADVERTISEMENT
Black History Month
February is Black History Month, celebrating the rich history of the African Diaspora in Brooklyn.
Gabourey Sidibe broke barriers, defied stereotypes and is defining her own success

Feb 18: Black History Maker, Gabourey Sidibe

February 18, 2019
Explore Black History Month

Recent Stories

Gabourey Sidibe broke barriers, defied stereotypes and is defining her own success
Black History Month

Feb 18: Black History Maker, Gabourey Sidibe

February 18, 2019
3-alarm fire burns through Fort Greene building containing apartments, businesses
In Other Brooklyn News

3-Alarm Fire Burns Through Fort Greene Building Containing Apartments, Businesses

February 18, 2019
Talib Kweli Kicked Off Valentine’s Weekend With A Love Note To Brooklyn
In Other Brooklyn News Featured

Talib Kweli Kicked off Valentine’s Weekend with a Love Note to Brooklyn

February 17, 2019
Permits Filed for 1694 St. Marks Avenue in Crown Heights, Brooklyn
In Other Brooklyn News

Permits Filed for 1694 St. Marks Avenue in Crown Heights

February 17, 2019
ADVERTISEMENT

Popular Stories

The Brooklyn STEAM Center will provide 300 students from eight local high schools with hands-on training in culinary arts, computer science, design and engineering
Fort Greene / Clinton Hill

Brooklyn Navy Yard Opens State-of-the-Art STEAM High School

February 13, 2019
The $500-million-Brownsville Plan promises to bring many developments and improvements to the neighborhood, but residents want a fair share as community stakeholders
Brownsville

Residents Call for Equity, Transparency in Brownsville Plan at Semi-Annual Meeting

February 8, 2019
The bakery was recognized with 2019 American Classic award which is given to locally-owned restaurants that are cherished for quality food reflecting the character of their community.
Bedford Stuyvesant

Bed-Stuy Trinidadian Bakery and Roti Shop Wins Prestigious James Beard Award

February 6, 2019
Bushwick Generator, Emerick Patterson, blockchain, decentralized communities
Business & Innovation

The Bushwick Generator is Creating a Blueprint for the Future of Urban Tech

February 1, 2019
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest from Instagram!

  • You are more in control than you think    exercise your power to say    no     It   s a slow but effective process of elimination  Happy Monday  BK Readers   bkreader  motivationmonday
  • Foster Care Unplugged  The Stage Play is a collaboration between Deus Beni Productions and the Brooklyn-based nonprofit organization Foster Care Unplugged  Every cast member is a current or former foster child  and the storyline is based on their real struggles  Click link in bio to read more       fostercare  foster  fosterparents  acs  adoption  play  fostercareunplugged  bkreader  mybklyn  4usbyus
  • Check it   Have you been by Radical Women BK yet on Jefferson and Tompkins in Bed Stuy  Well  if not  you should stop in this weekend and check out what the buzz is about  In the meantime  here   s an important new message from the co-owners  Repost from  alwayskimhill - My ponytail is installed so you KNOW this is BIG  Guess who   s joining forces with me at my  brickandmortar  radicalwomenbk   gbengaakinnagbe and his amazing brands  liberatedpeople    enitan vintage  And we   re looking for vendors of color who are looking to grow their brands and sing  jamesbrown songs with us   Peep the video and e-mail inquiries to radicalwomenbrooklyn gmail com  No DM   s please   hood hat by brotha  waajeed    blackexcellence  ponytails  diaspora  artists  actors  thewire  gbengaakinnagbe  kim  brooklyn  kimhill  nextofkimbeauty  naturalbodycare  livinginamerica  trayvonmartin
  • Happy Friday and Happy-Day-After-V-Day  BK Readers  Now go snatch up all of those 50  off heart-shaped boxes of chocolates          tgif  positivevibes  goodvibesonly  bkreader  mbklyn  4usbyus
  • Big Daddy Kane  born Antonio Hardy on September 10  1968  in Bedford Stuyvesant  is widely considered one of the most skilled MCs and charismatic entertainers in hip-hop   warmitupkane  Not only was he a gifted lyricist  but he was also a class act  always dressed    to the nines     effectively changing the face of hip hop fashion  To read this story and other local history makers  click our link in bio       bhm  bkreader  mybklyn  blackhistorymonth  blackhistory  brooklyn  bedstuy  4usbyus
  • Brooklyn Baby Sauce         Brooklyn resident  Think you re saucy  Take a picture and tag your location    Brooklyn    with a Brooklyn background or streetscape and you may be featured as our next  BrooklynSauce  as we showcase the diverse and unique flavors of BK   BrooklynSauce  SaucyBK  brooklyn  BKReader  MyBklyn        piccoliny
  • Repost from  cumbedance - CAPOEIRA  for adults at CUMBE  WITH  pena verde capoeira on Saturday   s WEEKLY for all of FEBRUARY  Take class with Pena Verde from 3-4 30PM  Drop-in is  16 and you can pre-register via our linktr ee cumbedance     capoeira  afrobrazilian  africandance  martialarts  africandiaspora  feelthejoy  cumbedance  bkreader  mybklyn  4usbyus
  • The New York City Health Department is cracking down on CBD-infused foods and drinks     with little to no warning for the establishments serving these items  To read story  click link in bio       cbd  cbdoil  cbdlife  bkreader
  • Chocolate lover  Then lay your eyes on this scrumptious chocolate mouse cake  courtesy the Chocolateria bakery  chocolate boutique  coffee shop and wine bar in Park Slope  Brooklyn  Here  they make vegan and gluten-free pastries          chocolateriaparkslope  chocolate  pastries  parkslope  winebar  coffeeshop  veganpastries  glutenfreepastries  bkreader  mybklyn  4usbyus
  • It   s what she wanted   bravegirl And she loves it    Check out the precision cuts at The Self Salon in Billieburg   selfsalon  brooklyn  bkreader  hairsalons r p  rockmamanyc

Newsletter

Get a roundup of the most important and intriguing stories from around Brooklyn, delivered to your inbox each day.

Neighborhoods

  • Bedford Stuyvesant
  • Brownsville
  • Bushwick
  • Crown Heights
  • East New York
  • Flatbush
  • Fort Greene / Clinton Hill
  • Prospect Heights

News

  • Arts & Entertainment
  • Business & Innovation
  • Health & Wellness
  • Lifestyle & Culture
  • Non-Profit & Community
  • Policy & Government

Letter from the Editor

Dear Brooklyn Readers,

Americans and their allies forced Germany to deal with its ugly past. The irony is, now, Americans struggle to do the same.

Read More
See Past Letters

Launched in 2013, BK Reader (formerly The Brooklyn Reader) is an online hyperlocal daily news source reflecting the art, culture, business and lifestyle of the fastest-developing areas of Central and East Brooklyn.

No Result
View All Result

2013 – 2018 © The Original Media Group LLC

  • Contact
  • About Us
  • Advertise

Privacy Policy  /  Cookie Policy

No Result
View All Result
  • Neighborhoods
    • Bedford Stuyvesant
    • Brownsville
    • Bushwick
    • Crown Heights
    • East New York
    • Flatbush
    • Fort Greene / Clinton Hill
    • Prospect Heights
  • News
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Business & Innovation
    • Health & Wellness
    • Lifestyle & Culture
    • Non-Profit & Community
    • Policy & Government
  • Features
    • Black History Month
    • Community Health
    • Gentrification in Brooklyn
    • Local Voices
  • About
    • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Advertise with Us
    • Write For Us
    • Contact

2013 - 2018 © The Original Media Group LLC

Logo

JOIN OUR NEWSLETTER

Local News for Brooklyn, by Brooklyn.
Arts, Culture, Health and Innovation.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.